George Ought to Help

http://www.georgeoughttohelp.com

Donate Bitcoins

Dec 17

Gun ownership vs murder rate by country

In the discussions following the recent Newtown shooting, several people have told me that data regarding gun ownership and violence supports the case for more restrictive gun prohibition. I believe that the above plots, on their face, discredit this view.

If all countries are included in the plot, there is a negative correlation between gun ownership and rate of homicide. Only when the plot is limited to OECD countries (with the outliers of US and Mexico included), does a very small positive correlation appear.

Disclaimer

Because of the many uncontrolled variables involved in comparisons between countries, I don’t believe such statistics can help the case for or against gun control. I’m posting them here to counter the claims by advocates of increased governmental gun control that the statistics legitimise their preference.

The plots above use data from the following sources:

List of countries by intentional homicide rate
Number of guns per capita by country

Thanks To

Mark Reid lately posted some gun control related plots and helpfully included instructions on how to recreate them using the statistics program R.

Diego Basch adapted the plots to compare intentional homicides against gun ownership.

Regarding the question of gun control, intentional homicides is a more relevant figure to look at than rates of gun-related deaths. This is because if an attacker expects that a victim may have a gun, they’ll be less likely to attempt any kind of attack.

For this post I recreated Diego’s plots by feeding R the same data sets, and getting it to draw regression lines for ease of reading.


  1. 3blake7 reblogged this from georgeoughttohelp
  2. notonetoblog reblogged this from georgeoughttohelp
  3. catspoliticsandnerdery reblogged this from theonecalledbiz
  4. theonecalledbiz reblogged this from anti-propaganda
  5. halo-0f-nembutals reblogged this from anti-propaganda
  6. automatonoverride reblogged this from anti-propaganda
  7. us2ginjo reblogged this from wellarmedvermonter
  8. wellarmedvermonter reblogged this from gunsgeargallantry
  9. gunsgeargallantry reblogged this from anti-propaganda
  10. behindthebarbedcurtain reblogged this from anti-propaganda
  11. svevenenanen reblogged this from anti-propaganda and added:
    all those unfired weapons…
  12. galactic-dust reblogged this from raw-r-evolution
  13. raw-r-evolution reblogged this from anti-propaganda and added:
    If people were not using guns, they would be using knives or hammers.
  14. everytimeidingles reblogged this from anti-propaganda
  15. silas216 reblogged this from anti-propaganda
  16. anti-propaganda reblogged this from antigovernmentextremist
  17. orneryjabroni reblogged this from occultagendas
  18. occultagendas reblogged this from anti-propaganda
  19. bigdaddykeith reblogged this from ignizzle
  20. warchanges reblogged this from ignizzle
  21. ignizzle reblogged this from phatdaddychrist
  22. sdgrave reblogged this from antigovernmentextremist
  23. nodiggityok reblogged this from anti-propaganda and added:
    “Because of the many uncontrolled variables involved in comparisons between countries, I don’t believe such statistics...
  24. fallingpizza reblogged this from anti-propaganda
  25. enkidarconquerstheworld reblogged this from antigovernmentextremist
  26. phatdaddychrist reblogged this from bigdaddykeith
  27. thezizzard reblogged this from sunnivaixchel-tumblr
  28. sunnivaixchel-tumblr reblogged this from athousandtinylives
  29. themovedmind reblogged this from anti-propaganda
  30. they-stole-my-robot reblogged this from basedheisenberg